Alright, so I've been called out in this little letter here. Guess it's my turn, huh? In your letter you state that Tom and I "have told us our reviews are destructive because they are not critical enough, and that we allow mediocre developers to pawn-off their wares on a gullible public, and that has to be accounted for." After reading that, I think it takes a little while to interpret what's being said here. I believe what you mean is that is your general consensus of what was said, and surely NOT that we told you that your reviews were destructive. What may surprise people here is what WAS really said by me, mainly because people are used to the censorship mentality from developers trying to protect their product. So, I'm going to use the good ole' number system and just state my points in a simple, yet (hopefully) effective manner and get out of here. So, here goes: 1. I believe you should be able to say whatever you want to say about a product, especially if you buy it. Regardless of such, I believe you should be able to say whatever you want to say even if you DON'T buy it! This is where I feel you guys fall short, simply because you are too worried about burning a bridge. We (at least at X-Aviation), have consistently told you to be as critical as you feel. X-Aviation takes this risk day in and day out with magazine reviews, online reviews (like Avsim.com), and even our own store review system. We have a live online store review system for people to share their thoughts and help other people make purchasing decisions. 2. I feel that the MSFS crowd needs to see what X-Plane can do from an honest point of view. You will earn respect and credibility from the masses when you're honest in your positive and negative views of a product. Remember...you're 'customers' are the users of X-Plane, NOT developers, so stop worrying about what we think when it comes to saying something good or bad about a product! It's like someone else said here: free media. 3. If your review is negative, chances are you aren't the only one that thinks so. You'll have a backing. If a developer truly cares about their customers and the product they are selling they will try and fix the product to meet the masses wants. This is similar to how we get bug fixes done. They are like mini-reviews from people that inform us what they feel is wrong with the product and where we need to improve. How do you think people would feel if we left everything unattended to? These three simple points are all I really have to say right now. You guys can do what you want with it. In my eyes, at this time, the only people being destructive are you guys to your own blog by not pushing forward amidst the raucous. Have faith...it works...in some form or another.